A Florida jury on Thursday began deliberating the fates of a man and woman facing murder charges in the killing of a Florida State University law professor who was entangled in a messy divorce and bitter child custody battle when he was gunned down five years ago in his garage.
During final arguments, prosecutors urged the jury to return guilty convictions against Katherine Magbanua and her ex-boyfriend, Sigfredo Garcia, who they say took part in a murder-for-hire plot with another man to kill Dan Markel.
Defence attorneys asserted that their clients were innocent scapegoats in the government’s failure to charge Markel’s in-laws, who prosecutors implicated throughout the trial.
And they hoped that the jury would reject the testimony of a key prosecution witness who pleaded guilty for his role in the slaying in exchange for a reduced sentence.
Markel, 41, was born in Toronto, where his funeral was held. His family still lives in the area.
He practised white-collar criminal defence and civil litigation before joining the Florida State University law school as a faculty member in 2005.
As described by prosecutors and defence attorneys alike during two weeks of court proceedings, the trial had all the makings of a Hollywood drama — hit men, bickering spouses, failed romances, money, drug trafficking and scheming in-laws.
Markel was shot to death after returning home from the gym and dropping off his two young children at day care on the morning of July 19, 2014, in Florida’s capital, Tallahassee.
A neighbour testified about seeing a light-coloured Prius speed away when he grew suspicious and decided to check on Markel. He discovered Markel in the garage, still in his car and bleeding from the head. Shards of glass littered the garage floor, and Markel had been shot twice in the head.
An investigation led authorities to Luis Rivera, who they say conspired with Garcia and Magbanua to kill Markel. Rivera and Garcia were childhood friends, and Garcia is the father of Magbanua’s two children.
The government said the three were paid $100,000 US to carry out Markel’s execution.
Rivera, under a plea deal, would later be a witness against Garcia and Magbanua.
Saam Zangeneh, Garcia’s attorney, attacked Rivera’s credibility.
Much of the government’s case against the two defendants relies on the testimony of Rivera, and Zangeneh asserted that the government is wrongly relying on Rivera, who he said was a known gang member.
“A gangster killed Dan Markel,” Zangeneh told jurors. “Luis Rivera killed Dan Markel.”
Defendant dated Markel’s brother-in-law
But Assistant State Attorney Georgia Cappleman said Garcia pulled the trigger on the gun that killed Markel and said Magbanua had enlisted the two men to execute the hit on behalf of the financiers who paid $100,0000.
If found guilty, Garcia could face the death penalty, while Magbanua could spend the rest of her life in prison.
Although the trial focused on Garcia and Magbanua, the courtroom drama was even more intriguing because of who was not on trial — despite repeated suggestions by prosecutors and defence attorneys of who might have been behind Markel’s slaying.
“What enemies had Mr. Markel made that set in motion such a brutal act?” Cappleman asked.
The answer, she said: “His own family.”
Indeed, lawyers for Magbanua and Garcia said their clients were only on trial because authorities had failed to bring charges against the relatives of Markel’s ex-wife, Wendi Adelson.
According to testimony, Magbanua had been romantically involved with Adelson’s brother, Charlie. Prosecutors say bad blood between the Adelsons and Markel led to murder.
However, no charges have been brought against any of Markel’s former in-laws.
Chris DeCoste, one of Magbanua’s attorneys, called prosecutors so desperate for a conviction that they put an innocent woman on trial.
“There’s no amount of money you could pay a mother of two for her to risk never seeing her children again,” DeCoste said.
“She’s been in custody for three years. It’s time for her to go home.”
- Democrats and Donald Trump will each get just 24 hours over TWO DAYS to make their case at impeachment trial, under Republican plan - and senators will debate rules behind closed doors tomorrow
- Jury selection in Weinstein case could prove to be drawn-out
- Jury selection begins in Bill Cosby retrial amid #Metoo movement
- Who might argue the case against Trump in the Senate impeachment trial?
- Why Baton Rouge man suspected of killing 2 black men might see his fate greatly impacted by law change
- Democrats lay out the case; Republicans close ranks
- House Dems to outline case for removing Trump from office
- Democrats add last-minute evidence to Trump impeachment case before Senate trial
- State voting, registration laws vary and change frequently
- Charles is 'hurt' after giving millions of his OWN cash to Meghan and Harry: Prince used private income to furnish couple's home and pay for wedding to 'help embrace daughter-in-law into family'
- Donald Trump goes on trial TODAY: Senators to open bitter partisan warfare on the rules as only the third president ever is tried - with Democrats slamming a 'cover-up' and poll showing 51% want him removed from office
- Emails reveal Harvey Weinstein's accusers 'bragged' about having sex with him and one even wanted to introduce him to her mother, his lawyer claims
- 'This isn't a trial - it's a COVER-UP!' Chuck Schumer rages against Mitch McConnell's rules for Donald Trump's impeachment trial as a 'national disgrace'
- Harvey Weinstein trial: Potential juror speaks of 'disgust'
- Donald Trump unleashes his loyalists to swarm the well of the Senate: President's firebrand defenders including Jim Jordan and Mark Meadows are out on his impeachment defense team
- #MeToo prosecutors deploy experts early to thwart defense
- Reforming the Prosecution and Justice Systems
- Trump chooses high-profile but controversial legal team
Florida jury deliberating in case of slain Toronto-born law professor have 946 words, post on www.cbc.ca at October 11, 2019. This is cached page on Auto News. If you want remove this page, please contact us.